Condensed from
a 1999 Bluewater Network
document.
According to snowmobile emissions data, in one hour, a single snowmobile produces more smog-forming
pollution than a modern car creates in one year; one hundred snowmobiles
can create the equivalent carbon monoxide of more than 100,000
cars.
Two-stroke engines deliver a lot of power but
also a lot of exhaust; they spit 100 times more carbon monoxide
and 300 times more hydrocarbons than automobiles, according to
a report compiled from studies performed by several state and
federal agencies and the University of Denver.
The EPA has determined that two-stroke engines
release between 25% and 30% of their unburned gas and oil mixture
directly into the environment.
For particulate matter concentration, the federal
limit is a concentrate of 60. As an example, at Yellowstone National
Park's west entrance on Feb. 13 and Feb. 14, 1997, the concentrations
were 116 and 122, respectively.
"To put this in perspective, the maximum 24-hour particulate
matter concentration in the Los Angeles suburb of Azusa in 1997
was 68," the report states.
These engines create dangerous levels of airborne
toxins including nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, ozone, particulate
matter, aldehydes, 1,3 butadiene, benzenes, and extremely persistent
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH). EPA lists several of these
compounds as “known or probable” human carcinogens.
Benzene, for instance, is a "known" human carcinogen. And several aldehydes including butadiene
are classified as "probable human carcinogens." All are believed to cause deleterious
health effects in humans and animals well short of fatal doses
(EPA 1993).
Two‑stroke engines also discharge 25‑30%
of their fuel mixture, unburned, directly into the environment. Unburned fuel contains many toxic compounds
including benzene, toluene, xylene and the extremely persistent
suspected human carcinogen MTBE.
Two‑strokes are one of the largest unchecked sources
of pollution nationwide. Charles
Emmett, an engineer with the California Air Resources Board, says
that snowmobiles are "extremely, extremely dirty compared
to anything else ... [s]nowmobiles are the worst there is."
(McMillion 1994).
A. Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons
(PAHs)
PAHs are by‑products
of fuel combustion found in high concentrations in unregulated
two‑stroke emissions.
They are particularly hazardous because they are both carcinogenic
and mutagenic, and are extremely persistent in the environment.
Dangerous levels of
carbon monoxide (CO) and particulate matter (PM) are a primary
concern. CO is extremely dangerous to humans (discussed
below), and particulate matter is a recently confirmed human carcinogen
by the EPA. Snowmobiles
emit dangerously high levels of carbon monoxide. A study conducted for the National Park Service in 1997 concluded
that a single snowmobile produces 500‑1000 times more carbon
monoxide than a 1988 passenger car (Fussell‑Snook 1997). Notably, comparisons to a current model‑year
passenger vehicle would increase this figure significantly.
C. Human Health Risks Associated
with Carbon Monoxide
The blue haze found trailing behind snowmobiles
contains not only dangerous levels of airborne toxins, but can
lead to the formation of additional ground level ozone from the
photochemical reaction of released nitrogen and hydrocarbons.
Health risks associated with exposure to smog and nitrogen
include respiratory complications such as coughing, chest pain,
heart problems, asthma, concentration lapses and shortness of
breath. Elderly individuals and children are particularly sensitive
to ground level ozone and nitrogen.
Carbon monoxide is particularly
dangerous because it binds to the hemoglobin in blood (forming
carboxyhemoglobin) and renders hemoglobin incapable of transporting
oxygen (Snook‑Fussell 1997).
Elevated levels of carboxyhemoglobin can cause neural‑behavioral
effects at lower levels (2‑3 percent), headaches and fatigue
(10 percent), and respiratory failure and death at higher levels.
And the general consensus among medical professionals is
that the health risk from CO increases at high altitude ‑‑
a risk exacerbated by richer fuel mixtures common at higher elevations.